Blog Section

HOW I DO – Common Questions asked by Cancer Patients to Doctors – PART 29

HOW I DO – Common Questions asked by Cancer Patients to Doctors – Part 29

  (All the articles published in past are available at www.shyamhemoncclinic.com/blog/)

Question: In last part, we discussed evaluation of Anemia with normal MCV, and most common causes. Including mainly 1. Importance of history and examination 2. Anemia of SIRS – inflammation as a reason for anemia – either acute or chronic 3. Mixed deficiency of iron, B12/folate 4. Kidney disease, even in mild cases and role of erythropoietin level and supplement 5. When to suspect bone marrow involvement.

Switching to Cancer patients needs. We have a significantly high number of cancer patients now in our practice, not sure why, but most of my colleagues in family practice also mention the same. And these patients have several questions. Can you give us some guidance about how to answer these? Related to Diet, Exercise, family members questions about prevention for them, why did the patient get the cancer even with no bad habits, which supplements to take, how many and what tests to do such as expensive scans and blood tests advised by their oncologist etc. They also search these topics and more on social media, AI platforms and come up with many questions. We really need some expert guidance. Most common question in India of course is DIET – What to Eat and What Not to Eat? And supplements too – OTC, Ayurvedic, Herbal etc

Answer: Same for us too. And i will tell you what we advise. I have also made short videos for patients to see. These are available on my clinic website, youtube, and they can also watch these by scanning QR codes on my visiting card/letterhead etc. These questions by patients related to Diet, Supplements and all the other points that you have mentioned are genuine needs. If we or a family member have cancer, we will have the same questions. Apart from treatment provided by an oncologist, patients and family want to ensure that every other corner is also covered. On top of this, there is very confusing advice available on social media, social circles, and AI. Hence patients definitely need guidance from their treating doctor, family doctor.

First, we have to acknowledge that they are also part of the team and they also wish the best results. However, as doctor, we have to guide them about the priorities first.

Que: Yes, diet is important but not more important than treatment itself. But how do you explain?

Ans: I make following points, and explain in a matter that suits patient education, understanding level, anxiety level about this etc. Some patients just want to know what you advise. While others want to know why, and want to check all the advice they have received.

  1. Treatment is the Main part which will give results. Diet is support.
  2. Dietary habits may or may not have led to cancer, in this individual case. But now is not the time to make very big changes in diet. Since diet changes take decades to lead to cancer. And healthy diet cannot cure cancer by itself or make big improvements in results.
  3. Making very big changes are very difficult for most patients. And most do not sustain for long. Expecting big changes puts a big psychological burden on patient and sometimes for the caregivers too. Patient is already facing big burden due to diagnosis, prognosis discussions, treatment related concerns, cost, Why Me etc.
  4. Make small changes in diet, something you can follow for longer period.
  5. Diet change will lead to improvements in cure or lifespan only if it can be followed for years, not for few months only during treatment.
  6. Very importantly, big diet changes frequently lead to initial weight loss, weakness, loss of interest in eating, depression. Especially for those who dont have self motivation for the same, but are forced by family members. And then feeling of guilt if they are unable to continue. Physical changes like weakness and weight loss have direct impact on our ability to deliver treatment. Such as unable to give full doses of chemotherapy or timely doses. HENCE I STRONGLY advise against big changes during active treatment period.
  7. Also, there is no clear scientific data to prove that big changes in diet during treatment will substantially impact treatment results. While it clearly can have negative impact as explained in last point.
  8. I tell them that major lifestyle changes should be done after treatment is completed or at least the initial critical component is completed. For that, we have scientific data to show that it reduces risk of relapse and improves survival in some cancers. And that i will guide you what to do once we complete the treatment.
  9. I in fact tell them to continue eating their regular diet to a large extent, except reduce or avoid outside food, due to hygiene concerns mainly.
  10. Not only this, many patients have very high sense of smell during chemotherapy treatment. Hence they cannot eat cooked food. They develop nausea with smell of our Indian masala used in vegetables, curry etc. Even roti and rice also smell too much for some people. Even a relative sitting in the same room and eating these foods gives them nausea and loss of appetite. For these patients, i advise foods with minimal or no smell. These include fruits, salads, juices, soups, cold milk, paneer, curd, dry fruits, milkshake etc milk products, ice cream, bread butter, sandwich, khakhra, mamra, biscuits, chips, cookies, most sweets, some farsan including fried foods etc. Patients are mostly very surprised since they now believe in very healthy foods, and will not eat maida (bread etc), sugar (no sweets), oil, processed foods etc. We have to repeatedly explain to them that priority right now is to ensure no weight loss, weakness and completion of timely treatment.
  11. I also explain to them that foods vary widely between different cultures in India, China, West etc. Hence there cannot be any one list of foods that is good for all patients. Non vegetarian food is staple in so many countries, and so many cultures. Italians eat pasta, pizza as their major foods etc. And yet we compare our results with results in Western countries.
  12. Only change i recommend is adding at least one fruit per day for most patients. Since research has shown that it improves gut microbiome health and that is connected to immunity. Also, patients on immunotherapy have better results if their gut microbiome is healthier.

 

November 14th  2026  Dr Chirag A. Shah; M.D. Oncology/Hematology (USA), 9998084001.  Diplomate American  Board  of  Oncology  and  Hematology. Ahmedabad. drchiragashah@gmail.com www.shyamhemoncclinic.com